The influence of congregations extends far beyond what is expressed openly in sermons, Bible studies, and hallway conversations. The issues congregants avoid and the concerns they keep to themselves are just as consequential. These silences shape what members consider important, what they perceive as off-limits, and ultimately how they interpret the world around them.
I observed the power of quiet omissions at a congregation I call “Welcome,” a new evangelical church in a growing Southern college town. The church was planted to be a place for “everybody,” regardless of age, race, class, nationality, or religious upbringing. When I began my ethnographic research there, I expected that differences would show up in congregants’ conversations as they discussed the church’s racial reconciliation efforts or women’s pastoral leadership, perhaps even in talk about the things ever-present in their community — such as religious freedom laws, electoral politics, or immigration.
But I rarely encountered such conversations. Instead, I noted how churchgoers skillfully avoided these topics, even as they directly affected members’ lives. Welcome operated under a largely unspoken rule: keep politics to yourself by withholding opinions that might provoke disagreement or challenge perceived majority views.
“Churchgoers remained silent on the very topics they cared about.”
In practice, this meant congregants and leaders never mentioned Trump, sidestepped debates over Confederate monuments, seldom addressed LGBTQ+ inclusion, and spoke only vaguely about white supremacy and far-right extremism. The result was not consensus but the appearance of consensus, which favored prevailing conservative views and curtailed opportunities for honest engagement across differences.
Churchgoers remained silent on the very topics they cared about not because they agreed with everybody else, but because they feared disrupting the church’s commitment to unity. That’s why I called the book I wrote Whispers in the Pews. These silences led members with moderately progressive views to believe their perspectives were unpopular, offensive, or out of step with the congregation. As a result, meaningful differences were pushed into the background of church life, and existing conservative norms, no matter how harmful, came to appear universally appreciated and valued.
That’s a challenge for leaders. Pastoring every member of a congregation – whether the predominant atmosphere is conservative or progressive – requires asking whether those who are not saying much feel secure enough to share their views. In doing so, leaders may gain a clearer understanding of what congregants fear, hope for, or struggle to express.
To tune into silence, leaders and observers must listen carefully. Which current events spark hushed asides but never surface in small group discussions? Which concerns emerge in one-on-one meetings only to vanish in more public spaces? Which topics generate energetic exchange, and which bring conversations to a sudden halt?
Tuning into silence also requires attention to the signals leaders send about what can and cannot be talked about. When leaders reference difficult events or contentious issues only indirectly or ambiguously, they may unintentionally communicate that some concerns are better left alone.
Broaching difficult realities is uncomfortable, yet that very discomfort can create space for thoughtful dialogue, inviting participation from members whose voices might otherwise remain hidden. Interviews and Focus Groups may help, but they will have to be carefully led. And if the congregation is offered a survey, the questions will have to be equally sensitive. But leaders who find ways to attend to what remains unsaid are best positioned to understand and care for all the people they serve.


